Shaping Contexts and Developing Invitational Ethos in Response to Medical Authority An Interview Study of Women Down Syndrome Advocates
Main Article Content
Abstract
In this article, we argue that Down syndrome (DS) advocates seeking to intervene in medical exigences are poorly positioned by their audiences of patients and physicians. To combat this problem, we find that some advocates, specifically mothers of children with DS, recuperate their ethos through two primary rhetorical strategies: shaping contexts and developing invitational ethos. Advocates are able to more freely draw from maternal authority when they shape the contexts of their messages, creating new venues and limiting their audiences. On the other hand, advocates can also appease medical authority by developing an invitational ethos in which they create the conditions for their own participation and offer their own perspectives. Through the use of these two strategies, advocates are able to claim their positions as mothers, while still cultivating positive ethos.
Article Details
References
ACOG practice bulletin no. 77: Screening for fetal chromosomal abnormalities. (2007). Obstetrics and Gynecology 109 (1), 217-227.
Berube, Michael. (1996). Life as We Know It: A Father, a Family, and An Exceptional Child. New York: Vintage.
Bone, Jennifer E., Cindy L. Griffin, and T.M. Linda Scholz. (2008). Beyond traditional conceptualizations of rhetoric: Invitational rhetoric and a move toward civility. Western Journal of Communication, 72(4), 434-462.
Britt, Elizabeth C. (2018). Reimagining Advocacy: Rhetorical Education in the Legal Clinic. University Park: Penn State UP.
Carey, Allison C. (2010). On the Margins of Citizenship: Intellectual Disability and Civil Rights in Twentieth-Century America. Philadelphia: Temple UP.
Cha, Ariana E. (2018). Babies with Down syndrome are put on center stage in the U.S. abortion fight. The Washington Post. Retrieved from https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/to-your-health/wp/2018/03/05/down-syndrome-babies-are-taking-center-stage-in-the-u-s-abortion-fight/?noredirect=on&utm_term=.580fdb111c99
Condit, Celeste M. (1997). In praise of eloquent diversity: Gender and rhetoric as public persuasion. Women's Studies in Communication 20(2), 91-116.
Daniell, Beth. and Guglielmo, Letizia. (2016). Changing Audience, Changing Ethos. In. K. Ryan, N. Myers, R. Jones (Eds.), Rethinking Ethos: A Feminist Ecological Approach to Rhetoric Carbondale (89-109). Carbondale: Southern Illinois UP.
De Graaf, Gert, Frank Buckley, and Brian Skotko. (2017). Estimation of the number of people with Down syndrome in the United States. Genetics in Medicine 19(4), 437-447.
DeLaure, Marilyn B. (2008). Planting seeds of change: Ella Baker's radical rhetoric. Women's Studies in Communication 31(1), 1-28.
Downey, Sharon D. (1997). Rhetoric as balance: A dialectical feminist perspective. Women's Studies in Communication 20(2), 137-150.
Foss, Sonja K. and Cindy L. Griffin. (1995). Beyond persuasion: A proposal for invitational rhetoric. Communication Monographs 62: 2-18.
Global Down Syndrome Foundation (GDSF). Down syndrome research and medical care timeline. Retrieved from https://www.globaldownsyndrome.org/about-down-syndrome/history-of-down-syndrome/research-and-medical-care-timeline/
Hayden Erika C. (2012). Fetal tests spur legal battle: a newborn industry based on non-invasive genetic testing turns combative. Nature 486, 454.
Iannone, Nancy. (2014). Keep abortion politics out of the pro-information movement. How Did We Get Into This Mess. Retrieved from http://www.thismess.net/2014/06/keep-abortion-politics-out-of-pro.html
Kaposy, Chris. (2018). Choosing Down Syndrome: Ethics and New Prenatal Testing Technologies. Cambridge: MIT Press.
Lozano-Reich, Nina M. and Dana L. Cloud (2009). The uncivil tongue: invitational rhetoric and the problem of inequality. Western Journal of Communication 73(2), 220-226.
Molloy, Cathryn. (2015). Recuperative ethos and agile epistemologies: Toward a vernacular engagement with mental illness ontologies. Rhetoric Society Quarterly 45(2), 138-163.
Montgomery, Kathryn. (2006). How Doctors Think: Clinical Judgment and the Practice of Medicine. New York: Oxford UP.
Myers, Greg. (1990). Writing Biology: Texts in the Social Construction of Scientific Knowledge. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.
National Down Syndrome Society (NDSS). Down syndrome fact sheet. Retrieved from http://www.ndss.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/NDSS-Fact-Sheet-Language-Guide-2015.pdf
Pennington, Mary Beth. (2016). Powerlessness repurposed: The feminist ethos of Judy Bonds. In. K. Ryan, N. Myers, R. Jones (Eds.), Rethinking Ethos: A Feminist Ecological Approach to Rhetoric Carbondale (150-172). Carbondale: Southern Illinois UP.
Pittman, Coretta. (2007). Black women writers and the trouble with ethos: Harriet Jacobs, Billie Holiday, and Sister Souljah. Rhetoric Society Quarterly 37(1), 43-70.
Reynolds, Nedra. (1993). Ethos as location: New sites for understanding discursive authority. Rhetoric Review 11(2), 325-338.
Ryan, Kathleen, Nancy Myers, and Rebecca Jones. (2016). Introduction: Identifying feminist ecological ethe. In. Kathleen Ryan, Nancy Myers, Rebecca Jones (Eds.), Rethinking Ethos: A Feminist Ecological Approach to Rhetoric Carbondale (1-22). Carbondale: Southern Illinois UP.
Ryan, Kathleen J. and Elizabeth J. Natalie. (2001). Fusing horizons: Standpoint hermeneutics and invitational rhetoric. Rhetoric Society Quarterly 31(2), 69-90.
Schmertz, Johanna. (1999). Constructing essences: Ethos and the postmodern subject of feminism. Rhetoric Review 18(1), 82-91.
Sheets, Kathryn B., Blythe Crissman, Cori Feist, Susan Sell, Lisa Johnson, Kelly Donahue, … Campbell Brasington. (2011). Practice guidelines for communicating a prenatal or postnatal diagnosis of Down syndrome: Recommendations of the National Society of Genetic Counselors. Journal of Genetic Counseling 20(5), 432-441.
Skinner, Carolyn. (2014). Women Physicians and Professional Ethos in Nineteenth Century America. Carbondale: Southern Illinois UP.
Skotko, Brian G., Susan P. Levine, Richard Goldstein. (2011). Self-perceptions from People with Down Syndrome. American Journal of Medical Genetics, Part A, 2360-2369.
Stern, Alexandra M. (2012). Telling Genes: The Story of Genetic Counseling in America. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins UP.
Szabo, Liz. (2013). With Down syndrome diagnosis comes a wrenching choice. USA Today. Retreived from https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2013/05/01/prenatal-tests-down-syndrome/2051237/
Wright, David. (2011). Downs: The History of a Disability. New York: Oxford UP.