The Politics of Standardized Patienthood
Main Article Content
Abstract
Standardized Patient Programs (SPPs) enlist actors to roleplay the symptoms of various diseases and disorders, and to embody a range of personalities. These simulations are used to help improve the communicative practices and professional competencies of future healthcare workers. Focusing on the use of these programs for medical students and doctors, this article establishes a kairology of the SPP to better understand the shifting terrains of patient representation. A kairological account focuses on “historical moments as rhetorical opportunities” (Segal, 2005, p. 23) and, in the case of medicine, illustrates how “changes in [medical] practice are importantly reciprocal with changes in the terms of practice” (Segal, 2005, p. 22). I trace the SPP through various linguistic iterations to reveal how the shifting language of simulated patienthood reflects different orientations towards medical pedagogy and patient populations at significant junctures in time. I conclude my kairology with an examination of the Indigenous Simulated Patient Program, a 2011 pilot program that has the potential to better represent and serve Indigenous peoples in medical pedagogy and practice.
Article Details
References
References
Association of American Medical Colleges. (2005). The changing representation of men and
women in academic medicine. Analysis in Brief 5(2), 1-2.
Barrows, Howard S. (1993). An overview of the uses of standardized patients for teaching and
evaluating clinical skills. Academic Medicine 68(6), 443-451.
------------------------. (1988, June 15-18). “Comments: The clinical teacher and the learning process.” In Barbara Gastel & David E. Rogers, eds. Clinical education and the doctor of tomorrow: Proceedings of the Josiah Macy, Jr. Foundation, National Seminar on Medical Education, Adapting Clinical Medical Education to the Needs of Today and Tomorrow. The New York Academy of Medicine.
------------------------ & Abrahamson, Stephen. (1964). The programmed patient: A technique
for appraising student performance in clinical neurology. Journal of Medical Education
, 802-805.
Berg, Marc & Timmermans, Stefan. (2003). The gold standard: The challenge of evidence-
based medicine and standardization in health care. Temple University Press.
Bowker, Geoffrey C., & Star, Susan Leigh. (1999). Sorting things out: Classification and its
consequences. MIT Press.
Campbell, Paul Newell. (1975). The personae of scientific discourse. Quarterly Journal of
Speech 61, 391-405.
Derkatch, Colleen. (2016). Bounding biomedicine: Evidence and rhetoric in the new science of
alternative medicine. University of Chicago Press.
Dolmage, Jay Timothy. (2013). Disability rhetoric. Syracuse University Press.
Epstein, Steve. (2007). Inclusion: The politics of difference in medical research. University of Chicago Press.
Ewan, Shaun C., et al. (2011). Indigenous simulated patient programs: A three-nation
comparison. Focus on Health Professional Education: A Multi-Disciplinary Journal 13(1),
-44.
Glauser, Wendy. (2018). Are physicians too busy to ask about patients’ concerns? Canadian
Medical Association Journal 190(40), 1214.
Groves, James E. (1978). Taking care of the hateful patient. The New England Journal of
Medicine 298(16), 883-887.
Haider, Adil H., et al. (2011). Association of unconscious race and social class bias with
vignette-based clinical assessments by medical students. Journal of American Medical
Association 306(9), 942-951.
Jack, Jordynn. (2014). Autism and gender: From refrigerator mothers to computer geeks.
University of Illinois Press.
Johnson, Jenell. (2010). The skeleton on the couch: The Eagleton Affair, rhetorical disability,
and the stigma of mental illness. Rhetoric Society Quarterly 40(5), 459-478.
------------------. (2014). American lobotomy: A rhetorical history. University of
Michigan Press.
Kempner, Joanna L. (2014). Not tonight: Migraine and the politics of gender and health.
University of Chicago Press.
Keränen, Lisa. (2010). Scientific characters: Rhetoric, politics, and trust in breast cancer
research. University of Alabama Press.
Kirkup, Kristy, and Ha, Tu Thanh. (2020, September 29). Indigenous woman records slurs, taunts of hospital staff before her death. The Globe and Mail.
Koerber, Amy. (2013). Breast or bottle: Contemporary controversies in infant-feeding policy
and practice. University of South Carolina Press.
-----------------. (2018). From hysteria to hormones: A rhetorical history. Pennsylvania State University Press.
Lampland, Martha & Susan Leigh Star, eds. (2009). Standards and their stories: How
quantifying, classifying, and formalizing practices shape everyday life. Cornell University
Press.
Lawrence, Katharine, et al. (2020). Building telemedicine capacity for trainees during the
novel coronavirus outbreak: A case study and lessons learned. Journal of General
Internal Medicine 35(9), 2675-2679.
Metzl, Jonathan, and Roberts, Dorothy E. (2014). Structural competency meets structural
racism: Race, politics, and the structure of medical knowledge. American Medical
Association Journal of Ethics 16(9), 674-690.
Molloy, Cathryn. (2020). Rhetorical ethos in health and medicine: patient credibility, stigma,
and misdiagnosis. Routledge.
Segal, Judy. (2005). Health and the rhetoric of medicine. Southern Illinois
University Press.
--------------. (2007). Illness as argumentation: A prolegomenon to the rhetorical study of
contestable complaints. health: An Interdisciplinary Journal for the Social Study of
Health, Illness and Medicine 11(2), 227-244.
Solomon, Martha. (1985). The rhetoric of dehumanization: An analysis of medical reports of
the Tuskegee Syphilis Project. Western Journal of Speech Communication 49(4),
-47.
Stillman, Paula L., & Swanson, David B. (1987). Ensuring the clinical competence of medical
school graduates through standardized patients. Arch Intern Med. 147, 1049-
---------------------. et al. (1980). Patient instructors as teachers and evaluators. Journal of Medical
Education 55(3), 186-193.
Tamblyn, Robyn M., & Barrows, Howard S. (1980). Bedside clinics in neurology: An
alternate format for the one-day course in continuing medical education. JAMA: The
Journal of the American Medical Association 243(14), 1448-1450.
Tamblyn, Robyn M. (1989). The use of the standardized patient in the measurement of clinical
competence: The evaluation of selected measurement properties. McGill
University PhD Dissertation.
Teston, Christa. (2017). Bodies in flux: Scientific methods for negotiating medical uncertainty.
University of Chicago Press.
VanPuymbrouck, Laura, et al. (2017). Experiential learning: Critical analysis of standardized
patient and disability simulation. Journal of Occupational Therapy Education 1(3), 1-13.
Wallace, Peggy. (1997). Following the threads of an innovation: The history of standardized
patients in medical education. Caduceus: A Museum Quarterly for the Health Sciences
(2), 5-28.
Wear, Delese. (2006). Respect for patients: A case study of the formal and hidden curriculum.
Professionalism in medicine: Critical perspectives. Eds. Delese Wear and Julie M. Aultman.
Springer, 87-101.
Zulman, Donna M., & Verghese, Abraham. (2021). Virtual care, telemedicine visits, and real
connection in the era of COVID-19: Unforeseen opportunity in the face of adversity.
JAMA: Journal of the American Medical Association 325(5), 437-438.