Main Article Content
Extensive evidence demonstrates that the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s multimedia anti-smoking campaign, Tips from Former Smokers, is an effective public health measure. In this essay, I explain the rhetorical appeals utilized in the campaign that contribute to its resonance, arguing that the campaign invokes corporeal anxiety, an emotion that emerges from societal aversion to disability. These appeals to corporeal anxiety operate as enthymemes by relying upon an unstated premise: that disability is negative and ought to be avoided to preserve one’s normalcy. This analysis treats the campaign messages as a form of bodily rhetoric and visual argument, arguing that the campaign deters smoking through graphic bodily imagery and narratives of lost normalcy that conceptualize disability as tragedy or deficit. I conclude that the success of the campaign comes at the expense of perpetuating stigma against people with disabilities.
Amos, Amanda, & Haglund, Margaretha. (2000). From social taboo to “torch of freedom”: The marketing of cigarettes to women. Tobacco Control, 9, 3-8.
Aristotle. (2007). On rhetoric: A theory of civic discourse (George A. Kennedy, trans.). Oxford University Press.
Arnett, Jeffrey Jensen. (2000). Optimistic bias in adolescent and adult smokers and nonsmokers. Addictive Behaviors, 25(4), 625–632.
Bayer, Ronald. (2008). Stigma and the ethics of public health: Not can we but should we. Social Science & Medicine, 67, 463–472.
Beasley, Vanessa B. (2020). The trouble with marching: Ableism, visibility, and exclusion of people with disabilities. Rhetoric Society Quarterly, 50(3), 166-174.
Bell, Kirsten, Salmon, Amy, Bowers, Michele, Bell, Jennifer, & McCullough, Lucy. (2010). Smoking, stigma and tobacco ‘denormalization’: Further reflections on the use of stigma as a public health tool. Social Science & Medicine, 70, 795–799.
Bernstein, Lenny. (2015). CDC alters anti-smoking ads after complaint from ostomy association. The Washington Post. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/to-your-health/wp/2015/04/21/cdc-alters-anti-smoking-ads-after-complaint-from-ostomy-association/
Bérubé, Michael. (2005). Disability and narrative. PMLA, 120(2), 568-576.
Birdsell, David S., & Groarke, Leo. (1996). Toward a theory of visual argument. Argumentation and Advocacy, 33(1), 1-10.
Birdsell, David S., & Groarke, Leo. (2007). Outlines of a theory of visual argument. Argumentation and Advocacy, 43(3-4), 103-113.
Bloomfield, Emma F., & Sangalang, Angeline. (2014). Juxtaposition as visual argument: health rhetoric in Super Size Me and Fat Head. Argumentation and Advocacy, 50(3), 141-157.
Bottorff, Joan L., Robinson, Carole A., Sarbit, Gayl, Graham, Raquel B., Kelly, Mary T., & Torchalla, Iris. (2015). A motivational, gender-sensitive smoking cessation resource for family members of patients with lung cancer. Oncology Nursing Forum, 42(4), 363-370.
Bourke, Joanna (2003). Fear and anxiety: Writing about emotion in modern history. History Workshop Journal, 55(1), 111–133.
Brewis, Alexandra, & Wutich, Amber. (2019). Lazy, crazy, and disgusting: Stigma and the undoing of global health. Johns Hopkins University Press.
Brown-Johnson, Cati G., Cataldo, Janine K., Orozco, Nicholas, Lisha, Nadra E., Hickman, Norval J., & Prochaska, Judith J. (2015). Validity and reliability of the internalized stigma of smoking inventory: An exploration of shame, isolation, and discrimination in smokers with mental health diagnoses. The American Journal on Addictions, 24, 410–418.
The campaign & the concerns. (n. d.). Fight colorectal cancer. https://fightcolorectalcancer.org/blog/our-response-action-to-the-cdcs-ostomy-ads/
Carpenter, Carrie Murray, Wayne, Geoffrey Ferris, & Connolly, Gregory N. (2005). Designing cigarettes for women: New findings from the tobacco industry documents. Addiction, 100, 837–851.
Carroll, Noel. (1996). Theorizing the moving image. Cambridge University Press.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2012a). CDC: Tips from former smokers – Brandon C.’s story [Video file]. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Fndx4mjCFY
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2012b). CDC: Tips from former smokers – Marie W.'s story [Video file]. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QivYVVtIMM0
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2012c). CDC: Tips from former smokers - Terrie H.’s tip ad [Video file]. https://youtu.be/5zWB4dLYChM
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2013). CDC: Tips from former smokers – Shane T.'s story [Video file]. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SCfWhVdkToE
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2015). CDC: Tips from Former Smokers - Julia C. and Mark A.’s Ad [Video file]. https://youtu.be/3q80UdOdP7o
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2016a). CDC: Tips from former smokers – Becky H.’s tip [Video file]. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IeVsQaJE5lI
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2016b). CDC: Tips from former smokers – Brian H.’s tip [Video file]. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WFPbXxU8Gwc
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2019). Current cigarette smoking among adults in the United States. http://www.cdc.gov/tobacco/data_statistics/fact_sheets/adult_data/cig_smoking/
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2020). Tips campaign matte article for military service members and vets. https://www.cdc.gov/tobacco/campaign/tips/press/articles/tips-matte-article-military.html
Chávez, Karma R. (2018). The body: An abstract and actual rhetorical concept. Rhetoric Society Quarterly, 48(3), 242-250.
Cherney, James L. (1999). Deaf culture and the cochlear implant debate. Argumentation & Advocacy, 36, 22–34.
Davis, Kevin C., Patel, Deesha, Shafer, Paul, Duke, Jennifer, Glover-Kudon, Rebecca, Ridgeway, William, & Cox, Shanna. (2018). Association between media doses of the Tips from Former Smokers campaign and cessation behaviors and intentions to quit among cigarette smokers, 2012-2015. Health Education & Behavior, 45(1), 52–60.
DeLuca, Kevin Michael. (1999). Unruly arguments: The body rhetoric of Earth First!, Act Up, and Queer Nation. Argumentation and Advocacy, 36(1), 9-21.
Dixon, Deborah P. (2016). Feminist geopolitics: Material states. Routledge.
Dolmage, Jay Timothy. (2013). Disability rhetoric. Syracuse University Press.
Dube, Shanta R., Arrazola, Rene A., Lee, Joann, Engstrom, Martha, & Malarcher, Ann. (2013). Pro-tobacco influences and susceptibility to smoking cigarettes among middle and high school students—United States, 2011. Journal of Adolescent Health, 52, S45–S51.
Dutta, Mohan J., & Boyd, Josh. (2007). Turning “smoking man” images around: Portrayals of smoking in men’s magazines as a blueprint for smoking cessation campaigns. Health Communication, 22(3), 253–263.
Emery, Sherry L., Szczypka, Glen, Abril, Eulàlia Puig, Kim, Yoonsang, & Vera, Lisa. (2014). Are you scared yet? Evaluating fear appeal messages in tweets about the Tips campaign. Journal of Communication, 64(2), 278-295.
The end of smoking. (2019). Action on Smoking and Health. http://ash.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/The-End-of-Smoking_final.pdf
Fairchild, Amy Lauren, Bayer, Ronald, Green, Sharon H., Colgrove, James, Kilgore, Elizabeth, Sweeney, Monica, & Varma, Jay K. (2018). The two faces of fear: A history of hard-hitting public health campaigns against tobacco and AIDS. American Journal of Public Health, 108(9), 1180-1186.
Finnegan, Cara A. (2001). The naturalistic enthymeme and visual argument: Photographic representation in the "skull controversy." Argumentation and Advocacy, 37(3), 133-149.
Fletcher, Brandon, & Primack, Alvin J. (2017). Driving toward disability rhetorics: Narrative, crip theory, and eco-ability in Mad Max: Fury Road. Critical Studies in Media Communication, 34(4), 344-357.
Garland-Thomson, Rosemarie. (2002). The politics of staring: Visual rhetorics of disability in popular photography. In Sharon L. Snyder, Brenda Jo Brueggemann, & Rosemarie Garland-Thomson (Eds.), Disability studies: Enabling the humanities (pp. 56-75). Modern Language Association.
Garland-Thomson, Rosemarie. (2009). Staring: How we look. Oxford University Press.
Gerber, David A. (2012). Introduction: Finding disabled veterans in history. In David A. Gerber (Ed.) Disabled veterans in history (pp. 1-52). University of Michigan Press.
Grinberg, Emanuella. (2012). Georgia's child obesity ads aim to create movement out of controversy. CNN. https://www.cnn.com/2012/02/07/health/atlanta-child-obesity-ads/index.html
Gustafsson, Karl, & Krickel-Choi, Nina C. (2020). Returning to the roots of ontological security: insights from the existentialist anxiety literature. European Journal of International Relations, 26(3), 875–895.
Harris, Gardiner. (2012). U.S. backs antismoking ad campaign. The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/15/health/policy/cdc-finances-nationwide-antismoking-ad-campaign-a-first.html
Harris, Jasmine E. (2019). The aesthetics of disability. Columbia Law Review, 119(4), 895-972.
Harris, Robert M., & Harris, A. Christine. (1977). Devaluation of the disabled in fundraising appeals. Rehabilitation Psychology, 24(2), 69-78.
Harold, Christine L. (2000). The rhetorical function of the abject body: Transgressive corporeality in "Trainspotting". JAC, 20(4), 865-887.
Hawhee, Debra. (2004). Bodily arts: Rhetoric and athletics in Ancient Greece. University of Texas Press.
Hawhee, Debra. (2011). Looking into Aristotle’s eyes: Toward a theory of rhetorical vision. Advances in the History of Rhetoric, 14, 139–165.
Hayles, N. Katherine. (1997). Corporeal anxiety in "Dictionary of the Khazars": What books talk about in the late age of print when they talk about losing their bodies. Modern Fiction Studies, 43(3), 800-820.
Hendrix, Harville. (1967). The ontological character of anxiety. Journal of Religion and Health, 6(1), 46-65.
Hughes, Bill. (2019). Invalidating emotions in the non-disabled imaginary. In Nick Watson & Simo Vehmas (Eds.) Routledge handbook of disability studies (pp. 89-101). Routledge.
Huang, Li-Ling, Lazard, Allison J., Pepper, Jessica K., Noar, Seth M., Ranney, Leah M., & Goldstein, Adam O. (2017). Impact of The Real Cost campaign on adolescents’ recall, attitudes, and risk perceptions about tobacco use. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 14(42), 1-11.
Hyde, Michael J. (1980). The experience of anxiety. The Quarterly Journal of Speech, 66, 140-154.
Jamieson, Kathleen Hall, Falk, Erika, & Sherr, Susan. (1999). The enthymeme gap in the 1996 presidential campaign. PS: Political Science and Politics, 32(1), 12-16.
Johnson, Jenell. (2010). The skeleton on the couch: The Eagleton affair, rhetorical disability, and the stigma of mental illness. Rhetoric Society Quarterly, 40(5), 459-478.
Johnson, Teddi Dineley. (2012). Hard-hitting public health ad campaigns sparking awareness: New tactics gaining results, controversy. The Nation’s Health, 42(5), 1-10. https://thenationshealth.aphapublications.org/content/42/5/1.3
Justice, Jacob. (2018). Corporeal anxiety: The visual argumentation of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s Tips from Former Smokers public service announcements. In R. Lake (Ed.), Recovering Argument (pp. 327-332). Routledge.
Kearney, Cassandra. (2020). A historical perspective on the "mental illness as motive" narrative. Rhetoric of Health & Medicine, 3(1), 34-62.
Kessler, Molly Margaret. (2016). Wearing an ostomy pouch and becoming an ostomate: A kairological approach to wearability. Rhetoric Society Quarterly, 46(3), 236-250.
Kjeldsen, Jens E. (2018). Visual rhetorical argumentation. Semiotica, 220, 69–94.
Knight, Amber. (2013). Disability as vulnerability: Redistributing precariousness in democratic ways. The Journal of Politics, 76(1), 15-26.
Landau, Jamie. (2011). Women will get cancer: visual and verbal presence (and absence) in a pharmaceutical advertising campaign about HPV. Argumentation and Advocacy, 48(1), 39-54.
Lazard, Allison, & Atkinson, Lucy. (2015). Putting environmental infographics center stage: The role of visuals at the elaboration likelihood model’s critical point of persuasion. Science Communication, 37(1), 6–33.
Lazard, Allison J., Mackert, Michael S., Bock, Mary A., Love, Brad, Dudo, Anthony, & Atkinson, Lucy. (2018). Visual assertions: Effects of photo manipulation and dual processing for food advertisements. Visual Communication Quarterly, 25(1), 16-30.
Lazard, Allison J., Schmidt, Annie, Vu, Huyen, Byron, M. Justin, Peters, Ellen, Boynton, Marcella H., & Brewer, Noel T. (2017). Icons for health effects of cigarette smoke: A test of semiotic type. Journal of Behavioral Medicine, 40, 641–650.
Lobel, Jules, & Loewenstein, George. (2005). Emote control. Chicago-Kent Law Review, 80(3), 1045–1090.
Lupton, Deborah. (2015). The pedagogy of disgust: The ethical, moral and political implications of using disgust in public health campaigns. Critical Public Health, 25(1), 4-14.
Mahoney, James. (2010). Strategic communication and anti-smoking campaigns. Public Communication Review, 1(2), 33-48.
Malkowski, Jennifer, & Melonçon, Lisa. (2019). The rhetoric of public health for RHM scholarship and beyond. Rhetoric of Health & Medicine, 2(2), iii–xiii.
Marshall, Caitlin. (2014). Crippled speech. Postmodern Culture, 24(3).
Mays, Darren, Turner, Monique M., Zhao, Xiaoquan, Evans, W. Douglas, Luta, George, & Tercyak, Kenneth P. (2015). Framing pictorial cigarette warning labels to motivate young smokers to quit. Nicotine & Tobacco Research, 17(7), 769–775.
McAfee, Tim, Davis, Kevin C., Alexander, Robert L., Pechacek, Terry F., & Bunnell, Rebecca. (2013). Effect of the first federally funded US antismoking national media campaign. The Lancet, 382, 2003-2011.
Miller, Elisabeth. (2019). Too fat to be President? Chris Christie and fat stigma as rhetorical disability. Rhetoric of Health & Medicine, 2(1), 60-87.
Miller, William Ian. (1997). The anatomy of disgust. Harvard University Press.
Myers, Matthew L. (2015). CDC shows sustained commitment to fighting tobacco with new anti-smoking ads - cost-effective campaign helps smokers quit. PR Newswire. http://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/cdc-shows-sustained-commitment-to-fighting-tobacco-with-new-anti-smoking-ads--cost-effective-campaign-helps-smokers-quit-300056458.html
Myres, Jason David. (2016). The bit player: Stephen Hawking and the object voice. Rhetoric Society Quarterly, 46(2), 156-175.
National Cancer Institute. (2008). Influence of tobacco marketing on smoking behavior. In Ronald M. Davis, Elizabeth A. Gilpin, Barbara Loken, K. Viswanath, & Melanie A. Wakefield (Eds.), The Role of the media in promoting and reducing tobacco use (pp. 211-291). U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
Neff, Linda J., Patel, Deesha, Davis, Kevin, Ridgeway, William, Shafer, Paul, & Cox, Shanna. (2016). Evaluation of the national Tips from Former Smokers campaign: The 2014 longitudinal cohort. Preventing Chronic Disease, 13(E42), 1-11.
Newman, Andrew Adam. (2014). Hard-to-watch commercials to make quitting smoking easier. The New York Times. http://www.nytimes.com/2014/07/25/business/media/hard-to-watch-commercials-to-make-quitting-smoking-easier.html?_r=0
Nichter, Mimi, Nichter, Mark, Lloyd-Richardson, Elizabeth E., Flaherty, Brian, Carkoglu, Asli, & Taylor, Nicole. (2006). Gendered dimensions of smoking among college students. Journal of Adolescent Research, 21(3), 215-243.
O’Gara, Erin, D’Silva, Joanne, Weiger, Caitlin, Villaluz, Nicole T., Piedra, Wendy, & Moran, Meghan Brigid. (2019). Restricting “natural” and “additive-free”: Did FDA’s agreement with Santa Fe Natural Tobacco Company change advertising for Natural American Spirit? Tobacco Regulatory Science, 5(4), 332-338.
Olson, Kathryn M., & Goodnight, G. Thomas. (1994). Entanglements of consumption, cruelty, privacy, and fashion: The social controversy over fur. Quarterly Journal of Speech, 80(3), 249–276. doi:10.1080/00335639409384072.
Ostomy Connection Editors. (2015). WOCN Society supports removal of a CDC video ad with ‘Julia's colostomy experience.’ Ostomy Connection. https://ostomyconnection.com/news-and-culture/wocn-supports-removal-of-cdc-colostomy-ad
Pfau, Michael William. (2007). Who’s afraid of fear appeals? Philosophy and Rhetoric, 40(2), 216-237.
PR Newswire. (2020, March 25). CDC's successful Tips from Former Smokers® campaign returns. Yahoo Finance. https://finance.yahoo.com/news/cdcs-successful-tips-former-smokers-220900634.html
Prochaska, Judith J., Gates, Emily F., Davis, Kevin C., Gutierrez, Karen, Prutzman, Yvonne, & Rodes, Roberts. (2018). The 2016 Tips from Former Smokers® campaign: Associations with quit intentions and quit attempts among smokers with and without mental health conditions. Nicotine & Tobacco Research, 21(5), 576–583.
Proctor, Robert N. (2011). Golden Holocaust: Origins of the cigarette catastrophe and the case for abolition. University of California Press.
Richardson, Sol, Langley, Tessa, Szatkowski, Lisa, Sims, Michelle, Gilmore, Anna, McNeill, Ann, & Lewis, Sarah. (2014). How does the emotive content of televised anti-smoking mass media campaigns influence monthly calls to the NHS Stop Smoking helpline in England? Preventive Medicine, 69, 43-48.
Sawicki, Nadia N. (2016). Ethical limitations on the state's use of arational persuasion. Law & Policy, 38(3), 211-233.
Schermer, Maartje. (2014). The cyborg-fear: How conceptual dualisms shape our self-understanding. AJOB Neuroscience, 5(4), 56-57.
Shapiro, Joseph P. (1994). No pity: People with disabilities forging a new civil rights movement. Three Rivers Press.
Siebers, Tobin. (2008). Disability theory. University of Michigan Press.
Sifferlin, Alexandra. (2014). Here’s the best way to get someone to quit smoking. Time. http://time.com/3374941/quitting-smoking/
Singer, Ross. (2011). Anti-corporate argument and the spectacle of the grotesque rhetorical body in Super Size Me. Critical Studies in Media Communication, 28(2), 135-152.
Smith, Elizabeth A., & Malone, Ruth E. (2009). ‘‘Everywhere the soldier will be’’: Wartime tobacco promotion in the US military. American Journal of Public Health, 99(9), 1595-1602.
Stanford School of Medicine. (2015). Stanford research into the impact of tobacco advertising: Springtime. http://tobacco.stanford.edu/tobacco_main/images.php?token2=fm_st121.php&token1=fm_img3559.php&theme_file=fm_mt010.php&theme_name=Fresh,%20Pure,%20Natural%20&%20Toasted&subtheme_name=Springtime
Strickland, April A., Taber, Charles S., & Lodge, Milton. (2011). Motivated reasoning and public opinion. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 36(6), 935-944.
Tinkler, Penny. (2005). Advertising. In Jordan Goodman (Ed.), Tobacco in history and culture: An encyclopedia, Vol. 1 (pp. 11-19). Thomson Gale.
“Tobacco Use in the Military.” (2018, June). Truth Initiative. https://truthinitiative.org/sites/default/files/media/files/2019/03/Truth_Military_FactSheet_FINAL.pdf
van den Berg, Jacob J., Bock, Beth, Roberts, Mary B., Stein, Linda A. R., Friedmann, Peter D., Martin, Stephen A., & Clarke, Jennifer G. (2014). Cigarette smoking as an expression of independence and freedom among inmates in a tobacco-free prison in the United States. Nicotine and Tobacco Research, 16(2), 238–242.
Wang, Caroline C. (1998). Portraying stigmatized conditions: Disabling images in public health. Journal of Health Communication, 3(2), 149-159.
Wendell, Susan. (1996). The rejected body: Feminist philosophical reflections on disability. Routledge.
Westen, Drew. (2008). The political brain. Public Affairs.
White, Cameron, Oliffe, John L., & Bottorff, Joan L. (2012). From the physician to the Marlboro Man: Masculinity, health, and cigarette advertising in America, 1946–1964. Men and Masculinities, 15, 526-547.
Winderman, Emily, Mejia, Robert, & Rogers, Brandon. (2019). "All smell is disease": Miasma, sensory rhetoric, and the sanitary-bacteriologic of visceral public health. Rhetoric of Health & Medicine, 2(2), 115-146.
Young, Stephanie L. (2015). Running like a man, sitting like a girl: Visual enthymeme and the case of Caster Semenya. Women's Studies in Communication, 38(3), 331-350.