Main Article Content
The public’s declining trust in health advice from traditional outlets has long been noted by scholars. But what makes alternative sources for health information appear more trustworthy to some audiences? In this analysis, the author traces the use of expertise and experience as forms of multivocality in the textual artifacts of Gwyneth Paltrow and her enterprise, Goop—specifically those that promote clean eating and detox diets. The analysis illustrates how Goop creates a superficially neutral platform for different voices that make the texts seem polyphonic and by extension more trustworthy given that readers can choose which health plan is right for them. But upon further analysis the author illustrates that Goop blends each voice so that they “move in step” as a choir, combining with Paltrow’s own voice, and ultimately creating an illusion of polyphony and masking a dominant homophonic message that ties together mandates to “ask questions,” empower ourselves, and embrace the assumption that young, slender bodies are signifiers of health and wellness.
Bahktin, Mikhail M. (1984). Problems of Dostoevsky’s poetics. University of Minnesota Press.
Belluz, Julia. (2018, July 27). “Is Gwyneth Paltrow’s Goop psuedoscience winning?” Vox. https://www.vox.com/science-and-health/2017/7/19/15988180/gwyneth-paltrow-goop-jade-egg-debunkers.
Bordo, Susan. (1993). Unbearable weight. Feminism, Western culture and the body. University of California Press.
Brodesser-Acker, Taffy. (2018, July 25). How Goop’s haters made Gwyneth’s Paltrow’s company worth $250 million. The New York Times Magazine. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/07/25/magazine/big-business-gwyneth-paltrow-wellness.html
Brogan, Kelly. (2019). Own your self: The surprising path beyond depression, anxiety, and fatigue to reclaiming your authenticity, vitality, and freedom. Hay House.
Brogan, Kelly. (2014, November 22). HIV and Pregnancy: Pharma Abusing Women? Kelly Brogan, MD: Holistic Women’s Health Psychiatry. https://web.archive.org/web/20150112121030/http://kellybroganmd.com/snippet/hiv-pregnancy-pharma-abusing-women/
Caronia, Letizia, & Chieregato, Arturo. (2016). Polyphony in a ward: Tracking professional theories in members’ dialogues. Language & Dialogue, 6(3), 395–421.
Caulfield, Timothy. (2016). Is Gwyneth Paltrow wrong about everything? When celebrity culture and science clash. Penguin.
Chivers Yochim, Emily, & Silva, Vesta T. (2013). Everyday expertise, autism, and “good” mothering in the media discourse of Jenny McCarthy. Communication & Critical/Cultural Studies, 10(4), 406–426.
Cros, Anna, Bassols, Margarida, Brunat, Gemma, & González, Carla. (2012). Television and the mediatization of knowledge: Discursive strategies in new TV formats. Catalan Journal of Communication & Cultural Studies, 4(1), 21–41.
Currid-Halkett, Elizabeth. (2017). The sum of small things: A theory of the asprirational class. Princeton University Press.
Derkatch, Colleen. (2018).The self-generating language of wellness and natural health. Rhetoric of Health and Medicine, 1(1-2), 132-160.
Fløttum, Kjersti. (2005). The self and the others: Polyphonic visibility in research articles. International Journal of Applied Linguistics, 15(1), 29-44.
Goop. (n.d.-a). What’s Goop? https://goop.com/whats-goop/.
Goop. (n.d.-b). Uncensored: A word from our doctors. https://goop.com/wellness/health/uncensored-a-word-from-our-doctors/
Goop. (2019a). Alzheimer’s Disease. https://goop.com/wellness/health/alzheimers-disease/.
Goop. (2019b). Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder. https://goop.com/wellness/health/adhd/.
Goop. (2019c). Candida and other yeast infections. https://goop.com/wellness/health/candida-and-yeast-infections/.
Goop. (2019d). Celiac disease and gluten sensitivity. https://goop.com/wellness/health/celiac-disease-and-gluten-sensitivity/.
Goop. (2019e). Depression. https://goop.com/wellness/health/depression/.
Goop. (2019f). Diabetes. https://goop.com/wellness/health/understanding-diabetes/
Goop. (2019g). Generalized Anxiety Disorder (GAD). https://goop.com/wellness/health/generalized-anxiety-disorder/.
Goop. (2019h). Hashimoto’s Thyroiditis. https://goop.com/wellness/health/hashimotos-thyroiditis-disease/.
Goop. (2019i). Heart disease. https://goop.com/wellness/health/heart-disease-symptoms-and-causes/.
Goop. (2019j). Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS). https://goop.com/wellness/health/ibs-symptoms/.
Goop. (2019k). Infertility. https://goop.com/wellness/health/infertility/.
Goop. (2019l). Polycystic Ovarian Syndrome (PCOS). https://goop.com/wellness/health/pcos-symptoms-and-causes/.
Goop. (2020). Goop PhD. https://goop.com/goop-phd/.
Gross, Alan G., Harmon, Joseph E. & Reidy, Michael. (2002). Communicating science: The scientific article from the 17th century to the present. Oxford University Press.
Gunter, Jen. (2017, December 1). Gwyneth Paltrow to feature doctor who thinks AIDS is a Big Pharma scam at In Goop Health. Dr. Jen Gunter. https://drjengunter.com/2017/12/01/gwyneth-paltrow-to-feature-doctor-who-thinks-aids-is-a-big-pharma-scam-at-in-goop-health/
Jasinski, James. (1997). Heteroglossia, polyphony, and The Federalist Papers. Rhetoric Society Quarterly, 27, 23-46.
Jasinski, James. (2001). Polyphony. The Sourcebook on Rhetoric. Sage Publications.
Kennedy, Michael, & Bourne Kennedy, Joyce. (2007). Homophony. In The Concise Oxford Dictionary of Music.: Oxford University Press. https://www-oxfordreference-com.proxy.seattleu.edu/view/10.1093/acref/9780199203833.001.0001/acref-9780199203833-e-4454.
Kjær, Katrine Meldgaard. (2019). Detoxing feels good: dieting and affect in 22Days Nutrition and goop detoxes. Feminist Media Studies, 19, 702-716.
Khazan, Olga. (2017, September 12). “The Baffling Rise of Goop.” The Atlantic. https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2017/09/goop-popularity/539064/.
Kolata, Gina. (2019, September 30). Eat less red meat, scientists said. Now some believe that was bad advice. The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2019/09/30/health/red-meat-heart-cancer.html.
Lessl, T. M. 1989. The priestly voice. Quarterly Journal of Speech, 75, 183-197.
Levenstein, Harvey. (2012). Fear of food: A history of why we worry about what we eat. University of Chicago Press.
Levenstein, Harvey. (1988). Revolution at the table: The transformation of the American diet. Oxford University Press.
Lieber, Chavie. (2018, May 29). Goop’s Winning Retail Formula? It Doesn’t Have to Pay for Its Stores. Racked. https://www.racked.com/2018/5/29/17391006/goop-pop-ups.
Metzl, Jonathan. (2010). Introduction. In Against health: How health became the new morality. Eds. Jonathan Metzl and Anna Kirkland. New York University Press.
Miller, Carolyn. 2003. The Presumptions of expertise: The role of ethos in risk analysis. Configurations 11(2), pp. 163-202.
Mull, Amanda.(2019, August 26). “I Gooped Myself.” The Atlantic. https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2019/08/what-goop-really-sells-women/596773/.
Murphy, John M. (1997). Inventing authority: Bill Clinton, Martin Luther King Jr., and the orchestration of rhetorical traditions. Quarterly Journal of Speech, 83, 71-89.
National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health. (2019, September 17). “‘Detoxes’ and ‘Cleanses’: What you need to know.” https://nccih.nih.gov/health/detoxes-cleanses.
Nichols, Tom. (2017). The death of expertise. Oxford University Press.
Oreskes, Naomi and Erik M. Conway. (2010). Merchants of doubt: How a handful of scientists obscured the truth on issues from tobacco smoke to global warming. Bloomsburg Press.
Paltrow, Gwyneth. (2019). The Clean Plate. Grand Central Life & Style.
Paltrow, Gwyneth, Loehnen, Elise, Fried, Andrew, Minoprio, Shauna, & Lillegard, Dane (2020a). Goop Lab [TV series]. Netflix Productions; Boardwalk Pictures.
Paltrow, Gwyneth, Loehnen, Elise, Fried, Andrew, Minoprio, Shauna, & Lillegard, Dane (Producers). (2020b, January 24). The health span plan (season 1, episode 4) [TV series episode]. In Gwyneth Paltrow, Goop Lab. Netflix Productions; Boardwalk Pictures.
Paoletta, Rae. (2017, June 22). “NASA calls Bullshit on Goop’s $120 ‘Bio-Frequency Healing’ Sticker Packs. Gizmodo. https://gizmodo.com/nasa-calls-bullshit-on-goops-120-bio-frequency-healing-1796309360.
Rifkin, William. (2010). Understanding expertise. In Susanna Horning Priest (Ed.), Encyclopedia of science and technology communication (pp. 922-923). Sage Publications.
Rothkopf, Joanna. (2017, December 1). Anti-medication Goop Summit expert claims AIDS treatment kills and GMOs cause depression. Jezebel. https://jezebel.com/anti-medication-goop-summit-expert-claims-aids-treatmen-1820919802.
Scott, Jennifer Bracken. (2016). Boundary work and the construction of scientific authority in the vaccines-autism controversy. Journal of Technical Writing & Communication, 46(1), 59–82.
Segal, Judy. (2005). Health and the rhetoric of medicine. Southern Illinois University Press.
Toumey, Christopher. (1996). Conjuring science: Scientific symbols and cultural meanings in American life. Rutgers University Press.
Vaagan, Robert W. (2007). Open Access scientific, electronic publishing and Bakhtinian dialogism. Westminster Papers in Communication & Culture, 4(2), 85–99.